The short version
Most operators who want back into freight brokerage would start a new company. Andrew Silver thinks that's the slow way to do it. Building a carrier network takes years no matter how good you are, and in a post-Montgomery world, a broker that opened two weeks ago has a hard time getting a shipper to take the call. Andrew co-founded MoLo Solutions in 2017 with the goal of building a top 5 brokerage, ran it on execution rules he learned at Coyote, and sold the company to ArcBest. He's spent the last three and a half years sitting out a non-compete and hosting The Freight Pod. With that non-compete now ending, he's lining up a private equity-backed acquisition of an existing broker. In this conversation, Andrew explains why he'd rather buy than build, why he's open to a company of anywhere from 40 to 1,300 people in any mode, and why he's more confident today than he was in 2017 that he can build a top 5 company.
Key takeaways
- Buying an existing broker skips the slowest part of starting over. Andrew doesn't want to spend two to three years going from zero to $200M in top line, because the carrier network underneath that revenue can't be speed-run. Buying a quality operator gives him a foundation in carrier compliance and network development on day one. He doesn't care much whether that foundation is flatbed, intermodal, or drayage, because the goal is to build a top 5 broker on top of it.
- Execution rules are easy to write and hard to make money inside. At MoLo, carrier reps knew which accounts had to be covered before they went home, and customer targets like 95% tender acceptance and 97% on-time weren't up for debate. The hard part is that hitting those numbers can cost margin, since a 24-hour pickup window gives you more cheap trucks than an on-time commitment does. Andrew's answer was leaders telling the story over and over about how that execution turned into growth, promotions, and raises.
- Contract freight is how you build a carrier network. In its first couple of years MoLo did $25-30M a year with one food and beverage shipper, and Andrew says the account was about network, not margin. Moving hundreds of loads on the same lanes gave MoLo 10 to 20 carriers it could quote off when bidding the next shipper, sometimes after losing $30 a load, 50 times, to learn the true cost of a lane. Companies that hired ex-Coyote leaders and told them to "do what you did at Coyote" often missed that depth.
- Trust carriers first, and expect to get burned sometimes. Andrew's example: pay a carrier $800 on a contract lane in a down market when the spot market would cover it for $650, knowing it will spike to $1,200 at peak. Some carriers will still walk when the market turns. When they do, he wouldn't necessarily cut them from the network, but he wouldn't put them on another contract lane either.
- Montgomery is going to push a lot of brokerage owners to sell. Owners who've spent 10 to 30 years building a business worth $10M or $200M can lose it to one bad accident, and nobody defines negligence or "safe" until a jury does. Add the noise about AI, and Andrew expects many of them to decide it's time to cash out. His approach is to over-invest in protection until that clarity exists.
- AI won't replace brokers who give shippers someone to hold accountable. Transportation managers need a throat to choke when something goes wrong, and an AI bot doesn't have one. Andrew also thinks it's too early for anyone in brokerage to be an AI expert, so he isn't worried about starting behind.
Chapters
| Time | Topic |
|---|---|
| 00:00 | Intro: The Freight Show meets The Freight Pod |
| 02:42 | Three and a half years out of work and why Andrew started a podcast |
| 07:02 | Andrew's default operating mode as a CEO |
| 09:12 | The 2020 360 review and the perfectionism problem |
| 12:18 | Why every brokerage mistake reaches the customer |
| 14:55 | System vs. culture: guardrails around commitments |
| 17:21 | Storytelling and trading margin for execution |
| 22:03 | The 11th person in the row: what culture really is |
| 25:40 | What MoLo did right |
| 27:39 | Simple concept, hard execution |
| 29:11 | Using contract freight to build a carrier network |
| 30:38 | Why "just do what you did at Coyote" often failed |
| 31:29 | AI bots don't have throats to choke |
| 34:12 | Managing the contract vs. spot split through the cycle |
| 37:30 | Trusting carriers first |
| 40:04 | What to do when a carrier breaks the deal |
| 41:29 | What's changed in brokerage over 10 to 15 years |
| 43:45 | The non-compete ends: getting back in the game |
| 44:26 | Build from scratch or buy? |
| 46:24 | Why a new broker is a hard sell after Montgomery |
| 48:43 | Why brokerage owners should be scared |
| 53:26 | Someone's gotta move the freight |
| 55:49 | AI and the coming consolidation |
| 59:00 | The Rich Products story: 120 loads in a month |
| 1:04:05 | Buying with private equity, from 40 to 1,300 people |
| 1:05:31 | What Andrew wants 12 months from now |
Notable quotes
"Regardless of what I trained this new person on, over time they will act like the person on their left and the person on their right. And that's culture."
"We didn't have that account to make money. We had that account to develop a network."
"One of the reasons I don't see people and brokers getting replaced is because AI bots don't have throats to choke."
"If you want to build strong relationships with this network in this industry, you have to be willing to trust first, and also be comfortable getting burned from time to time."
"At the end of the day, someone's gotta move the freight. Why not me?"
Auto-transcribed via Riverside. Speaker labels are approximate; light cleanup applied.
Full transcript
[00:02] Jesse:
Alrighty, welcome everyone to another episode of The Freight Show. I've been excited to do this one with you, Andrew. I will say when I launched The Freight Show, it wasn't lost on me that there was already a Freight Pod in existence. But I thought, you know what, fuck it, I'm gonna name it The Freight Show and just roll with it. But I'm excited to chat. In a lot of ways, I feel like what you've done for the industry with The Freight Pod has been super cool. I think it was pretty unique, bringing to life and telling the stories of many of the people that have shaped the space, and I've been a longtime listener as well. You're obviously one of those people in the industry as well. So I'm excited to be hearing a little bit more about your story and getting your perspective on things that are going on.
[00:50] Andrew:
Thank you, sir. Happy to be here. Yeah, I'm usually on the other side, so it's kind of relaxing to come in feeling no pressure to perform. I guess when I used to go on podcasts, I would think I have to be my best. Now I've spent so much time on the other side of it, where I'm the interviewer and there's all this pressure to do everything right. You're accountable to the whole thing. Now I'm not remotely worried about what I say. I'm just relaxed at the idea that you're the one who's got to put out a show. I'm just the guest.
[01:29] Jesse:
Yeah. Well, for better or worse, my philosophy with this stuff is I'm genuinely just interested, and I like talking about topics that people know a lot about. So I just try to not overthink it as well and kind of go where my mind wants to go. I wanted to ask: it seems from the outside, in listening to your podcast, that the last few years have been a period of a lot of self-reflection for you. There's this theme that comes up a lot in your episodes about your own leadership journey, but then also what being more public and more open, and starting to have a persona where you're sharing more of yourself more broadly, has also had its own impact. So I'm curious, to the extent that you're now a professional media guy, and I'm teasing you a little bit, what has changed for you? What have been your learnings in doing The Freight Pod and things like it?
[02:42] Andrew:
So there's a lot to touch on there. For one, I've spent three and a half years out of work, and certainly in a forced situation where I couldn't just pick up and go back to work. So have the last few years been reflective? Yeah, if anything, because what other choice do I have than to reflect? It's not like I could just go back and grind the work circuit again. That wasn't really an option for me. And I think too, the way in which I left my last company, there was just a lot of wanting still. It's not like everything was wrapped up in a bow and I was ready to move on to my next chapter. It was more like it was decided on my behalf that I wasn't gonna work anymore at this company. And that's fair, but I think for me it did force me to spend a lot of time thinking about myself and how I was in my role and areas that I was failing. Being a podcaster now for a few years, initially this was just a way to... I was always thinking long term about getting back into brokerage and always wanting to be running a brokerage again down the road. And I thought, if I can't work for three and a half years, how do I keep myself relevant in the industry, relevant to the conversations that are happening, to what's going on in the market, to customers, competitors, what have you? That's where the first concept of a podcast became serious for me. I had talked about it, I'd thought about it in the past as just a way to market our business, but now it was more like this is a tangible way for me to stay involved, stay connected. What I didn't expect was the development of the relationships that would come out of it.
[04:59] Andrew:
In some cases, it's transactional. I get a lot of people reaching out to me asking to be on the show, or I reach out to them and ask them to come on the show, or I reach out to their marketing department. And sometimes, yes, someone wants to come and just have a conversation, but often it's a means to an end for someone. They wanna market their business, they wanna feed their ego, whatever the heck it may be. People enjoy hearing themselves talk. But I guess I didn't really expect that it would help me further develop a network in this industry. Even if the intent on one side had been transactional, to just get their brand out there or for me to get an episode out, at the end of the day it put me in a room virtually with someone and allowed us to have a conversation for sixty to ninety minutes about their business, and it just was a fun thing to do. And it has been a fun thing to do. I kinda hate a lot of the podcast process. I hate posting on LinkedIn about it. I hate writing the summary of the episodes. But the second we hit record and start talking, I love it. I really do enjoy that part of the process. So it's been fun getting to meet a lot of the smartest people in this industry, some of the hardest working, most successful people in this industry, and try to dig into their brains a little bit and understand how they tick, what they value, what's important to them, what they think matters in building a successful company.
[06:34] Jesse:
Yeah, totally. You mentioned that being reflective wasn't something you necessarily chose. I obviously didn't know you when you were an operator. What do you feel like was your default operating mode? What did you look and feel like when you were in the driver's seat?
[07:02] Andrew:
I think for one, the image I had in my head of who I was and the reality that my people navigated were probably not perfectly aligned. And that's probably the lightest way of saying that, or the nicest way of saying that. I think by default I'm pretty intense and set pretty high expectations, but in a manner that's centered on excellence and trying to be the best at what we're doing. I'm super competitive, and that competitive nature shows up in everything I do. So I think we set a really high bar, but I think we were also very intentional about being out front and on the front lines with the team doing the work. It was fun to do the work, but at the same time it was super stressful. And I think the downside to my instinctive operating mindset is that I could be super reactive, emotionally reactive, certainly three, four, five years ago. That's where a lot of the reflective work has come in, where it's like, okay, where was your intensity? Where were some of your character defects impacting the business in a negative way? And how do we make sure we don't show up the same way the next time around? Take the best of what we had and keep that, and then get rid of all the parts that were detracting from our success.
[08:54] Jesse:
You mentioned that there were differences between maybe your own mental image and reality. Was it feedback that you got? Where were the areas where you felt like there was that delta?
[09:12] Andrew:
Well, at one point I had an executive coach. She's awesome, if there are executives listening to the show, especially in Chicago, but I think she does it everywhere. She was great. She had me do this 360 feedback loop with my team. This was probably 2020, so we were maybe five years into the business at this point. And it was just clear that I had been ignoring some of the pertinent elements of how I was showing up. We were running so fast. We were moving a million miles an hour and growing super quickly, and COVID was going on, and it constantly felt like our hair was on fire a little bit. When you're operating at that kind of pace, it feels acceptable to let lesser quality attributes show up and be like, it's okay, we're moving a million miles an hour. So I just think there were points where I was too critical. I was listening to someone the other day talk about being a perfectionist, and I was thinking about myself in the business, and I think perfectionist is a word people would use to describe me. And I also think the word asshole could be synonymous with perfectionist, in how you communicate that desire for excellence, right? Because we all screw up, we all make mistakes, and it's an imperfect business. You're navigating fifteen things at a time. Things are naturally gonna miss here and there, and it's how do you navigate those challenges when they show up, versus holding people to the highest expectation and then, when they make a mistake, coming down hard on them.
[11:26] Jesse:
Yeah. I mean, it is a tough one, right? In a lot of ways I feel like as a founder of a business, certainly as a CEO, you are the ultimate arbiter of standards. And it's very easy to let a drop in standards just permeate things. But then how do you do that in a way where you're not always the prick who's throwing the bucket of ice water on everything and nothing's ever good enough? Because that is also very demotivating. But at the same time, people want to be on winning teams where the work is exceptional. It's not frictionless to create that standard.
[12:18] Andrew:
Well, the other challenge too is, I don't know why Apple's the first one that comes to mind, but it's not a business like Apple where the mistake doesn't show up in the product. It's not a situation where someone makes a mistake and the end customer doesn't really feel it. In brokerage, our whole business is centered on that exceptional execution concept. The only way we grow, in my opinion, and stand out, is through this level of excellence in execution. So when we fail on a load because someone put PM instead of AM, or we booked a bad driver who wasn't going to be empty in time, whatever, when those little things happen, the end customer feels that. And when they do, that's what detracts from your ability to succeed. So it's a fine line to toe between wanting people to believe in and strive for this excellence while also not demotivating them every time they make a mistake by coming down so hard on them about the expectations and how important it is that the expectations are met. So I don't know.
[13:46] Jesse:
Yeah. I've also never brokered freight, but sitting on the floor with folks, the thing that does strike me is how many things you have to do in order for things to move smoothly. How do you build in that rigor in a brokerage, from your perspective? Because there's one aspect of it which is, hey, try harder and give more shits. But then I'm sure the other piece of it is, well, people are not gonna be perfect, therefore the process needs to be good, the system needs to be good, there need to be checks and balances to capture this stuff. I'm curious if you think that framing is right, or how you think about building a system of operational excellence as much as a culture, or what the balance is between those two.
[14:55] Andrew:
Yeah, so system and culture. The system to me is pretty simple. It's setting up guardrails and ground rules around delivering on the commitments that you make. To me that part's not very hard, designing the system. Making money within a system around execution at the highest level, that's hard, and that takes a lot more nuance. But simply accepting a hundred orders from shipper A and then creating a system to execute the hundred orders, meeting the requirements set, to me is pretty straightforward and simple. It's how you structure the carrier group around meeting the expectations required. There's nuance in that, right? I remember almost hiring someone a long time ago, when he was working for a different brokerage. He did a short time for an asset-based broker. And I remember him telling me, "Yeah, I'm not allowed to cover the load unless it has at least 20% margin. If I don't find a truck at 20%, we give the load back." So that's what I'm talking about with the specific rules within the system. For me, what we had in my last business, and would have in future businesses, is a pretty clear set of rules around executing based on meeting the commitments we make, whether it's to move one load or a hundred loads. That part's not hard.
[16:50] Andrew:
Culturally, it can be more challenging, because there is often a contradiction between the amount of money you can make on a given order and your ability to execute it to the required guidelines. So if you take a hundred orders and you want to be on time for all hundred of them to pick up and deliver, you have fewer carrier options than if you say, I'll give myself a 24-hour window to pick all these up. Even if that pisses off the customer, you can make more money if you roll 30% of the loads. So culturally it's a little more challenging, but this is where what I believe is one of the more important leadership concepts comes in: storytelling, and really just being in front of your people enough, helping them understand why you do what you do and why the rules you set work. One of the things we did very well in a past life was helping people understand why we had these hard-set rules around execution, service, meeting these KPIs, even if it meant moving at 13% instead of 18%, or 9% instead of 12% margins. The stories were always centered on how our execution helped us grow and eventually make more money and be a better company in the long run. When you're constantly reiterating and showing people why what you're doing works, especially as the CEO, as the leader of the company... people are looking for someone in charge to tell them whether they're doing a good job or not. People want that. People want to be told they're doing well. People want to be congratulated for a job well done. And that's the leader's job: to set a foundation within the culture that's ingrained in promoting quality work and helping people realize that when you do the right things, that's what leads to us growing, that's what leads to us hiring more people, giving more promotions, giving more salary bumps. When you can tie those end results they want to the work you're asking them to do, that's how you get buy-in, in my opinion, and that's how you set it within the culture. If that makes sense. I don't know if I'm still even answering your question or if I'm just talking nonsense.
[19:18] Jesse:
No, it's interesting, because one of the things that I notice in logistics, and it's true of even how brokers relate to carriers, is you're talking about these decisions: do you do the right thing for the long term, or do you try to cut a corner and take a win now, but then what are you giving up? If you're short-sighted, there's a lot of incentive everywhere in logistics where you could cut a corner.
[19:49] Andrew:
In the world. It's maybe the most pertinent question in society and capitalism and business. Look at AI, the whole notion of AI doomers versus it's gonna save us or it's gonna kill us all. I'm kind of in the camp that I have a fear that it'll kill us all. Why? Because history has shown that we will always do what's in our best short-term self-interest, what makes us the most money today. As a society, history shows that's what we do. So setting better guardrails for AI to ensure that there's a safe process to the development of it, we're not doing that, because everyone wants to be first. They will risk safety in order to be first, because that's how capitalism works. I'm not against capitalism at all. I support it. It just scares me a little bit in this specific area.
[20:44] Jesse:
Totally. Well, maybe we'll park the "is AI gonna kill us all" question.
[20:49] Andrew:
Yes, I didn't mean to bring us down that path.
[20:51] Jesse:
No, I like it. But I think you're right. I feel like a lot of business is really understanding your flywheels well, right? What are the things that you are doing now that are creating more things for you in the future? And what you're talking about is that, right? If you execute well and you do what's right, and you take a nine percent on this because you made a commitment and not the thirteen percent, then you're gonna get a hundred more ten percents in the future, and that's much better for the business, and it's also what is good for the customer. And it's kind of interesting, because people talk about culture as being a thing that is different from strategy. They're like, hey, what's your strategy, and then what's your culture? But it's kinda like what you're saying: the culture has to reinforce what it is you're building. What you're drilling in needs to actually reinforce how you're approaching things. And it seems like that "do what you say you're gonna do over and over again, because you'll build deeper relationships" is maybe a piece of how you thought about it.
[22:03] Andrew:
Yeah, it's funny, I just now remembered this. I haven't said this in a long time, but I used to use this when I had a real job and talked about culture, because I do think it's the best illustration of culture. Imagine in a pre-COVID world, or a post-COVID world where your employees work in the office, you have ten people sitting in a row doing their jobs. Everyone's on the floor, they've all been employees a long time, there's no one training them right now, they are doing their jobs. I'm gonna take a new person, the 11th person, and put them right in the middle of those 10. Regardless of what I trained this new person on, over time they will act like the person on their left and the person on their right. And that's culture. So if you have the person on your left and the person on your right on the phones hanging up on carriers, because it's easier to hang up than to realize the rate's not gonna work and have a full conversation back and forth about it, or they're lying to carriers, they're lying to shippers, if that's what's happening in your business on a day-to-day basis, that is your culture. And when I add more people to it, even if I give them all the best training day one, I say, hey, never lie, never cheat, never steal, just to use those three examples, and they go into that role with that mindset, over time, as they see the people to their left and right cheating, lying and stealing, they'll start to lie, cheat, and steal too. That's just the nature of how people are. It's how people work. And I think it's a really healthy way of understanding that culture is not a thing. It's not something you can touch. It's a way that people operate. That's your culture. And I think that's often misunderstood, or maybe it just becomes such a big word that people try to bucket a million different things into it. But to me, that is what culture is.
[24:02] Andrew:
And in our business, there are thousands and thousands of brokers, and everyone has learned all the right buzzwords to say for a customer to be interested in them, for a carrier, for a podcast, for LinkedIn posts. Everyone's learned how to say all the right things. But to me, the real differentiator across businesses is what's happening on the floor between those reps and how they're operating. That's where I spend a lot of my time and energy thinking in building a business: how do I get to the root of what's happening right here and make sure that all of the boxes I want checked are being checked in terms of how these people are showing up and engaging everybody.
[24:42] Jesse:
Yeah. You've had a front row seat. I know you also worked at Coyote, you've built an amazing business, you've worked at them, you've seen them, and I know you're close with other folks in the ecosystem. I'm curious, when you think about how to win in brokerage, maybe five or ten years ago, and then if anything has changed now, what are the big pillars that need to be true? What do you think allowed you to have the success that you did with MoLo? What do you think you did right?
[25:40] Andrew:
Specifically around MoLo, I think one of the things we did very well was executing within the rules that customers set for us. There just was not really ambiguity. Okay, the customer said this is our lane, we have to accept 95% of the tenders and operate at 97% on time. There weren't questions around how should we do it. It was just, we need to meet those numbers. And doing so put us on a pretty extensive growth path where every year, by and large, going into RFP conversations, we were likely in a position to grow. You generally know with a shipper: I'm either in a position to grow, I'm hoping to stay at the same level, or I'm just hoping not to get kicked out of the network. Those are really the three stages you could be in with a shipper. And most of the time we felt pretty confident we were in a position to grow, assuming our pricing was gonna be good. So I think that was one piece. And that again comes down to the rules you operate within your business. How are you structured? Our carrier department was structured in a way where these folks knew which accounts, undoubtedly, before they left for the day, if there were loads on the board, they had to get covered. It wasn't some innovative thing we'd come up with. We learned that at Coyote, and I think at Coyote they learned it from Backhaulers. It's been done before. And I think there's a spectrum to the degree to which you take that.
[27:21] Jesse:
You're making it sound quite simple, but it must be hard to do.
[27:30] Andrew:
The concept is simple, the execution is hard.
[27:33] Jesse:
Right. What makes it so hard? When you look at other folks and that RFP comes up, why do they struggle?
[27:39] Andrew:
What makes it hard is the market's unpredictable. Pricing is unpredictable, and you can't really price everything definitively knowing your costs as a middleman. You can know your internal costs, but you can't know your truck costs. And even if you have the best partners on the carrier side, you still can't know how they're gonna... well, you do know how they're gonna respond in 2020 when COVID hits. When panic buying is happening left and right and rates are four times what they were a month ago, even the best relationships don't necessarily survive that, because they're still gonna want to get the market pricing. So where it gets really challenging is strategically managing your volume of contract versus spot. That balance is important. You're making bets. They're strategic bets. You're trying, as well as you can, to understand what market you're in today, what market you're gonna be in six months from now, and then make decisions on how aggressive you wanna be on your RFP bids, knowing that you're making some investments to develop a network.
[29:02] Andrew:
I think that's another thing: you have to take a few steps back, or zoom out a little bit. We had a relationship with a large food and beverage company that we were doing at one point probably 25, 30 million annually with in our first couple of years. And for me, I cared about us making money, but we didn't have that account to make money. We had that account to develop a network. We needed a carrier network. And you can't build a carrier network on spot freight. Maybe you can if you have gargantuan amounts of it, and it would take a long time. But you build a strong carrier network through contract business that's repeatable and high volume. Then you're doing hundreds of loads with the same carriers over and over again, and all of a sudden you have corridors developed. Call it Los Angeles to Phoenix, a pretty common lane that a shipper might have. The next time you bid for a new shipper, you're not just bidding off of a couple of spot carriers you've moved in the past. You have 10 or 20 carriers that run that lane consistently for you. You have much higher confidence that you can quote with a margin that you can keep. But you can't see that in the hundreds and hundreds or thousands and thousands of beer loads we moved to develop that part of the network. You don't see it in those dollars. Like, we lost $30 on this load 50 times to understand that our true cost on that lane is going to be X dollars.
[30:38] Andrew:
So there's just a lot more nuance in the actual execution, but the concept is simple, and this is why a lot of people did it. There have been a lot of companies that hired former Coyote people, put them in charge, and literally said something along the lines of, just do what you did at Coyote. And a lot of the people that got put in these roles didn't understand the depth of the strategy there. They just thought, okay, I'll come in and tell them we gotta cover every load we commit to, because at the highest level, that's the simple nature of it. And way more often than not, that process would fail over time, because it's just not that simple. There's a lot more to it. It's treating the carrier like they're a customer.
[31:23] Jesse:
Because you can cover every load, but doing that and building a sustainable business can be hard to balance.
[31:29] Andrew:
Yeah, subsidizing. I was just gonna say, we've seen examples of companies taking loads and loads, literally a lot of loads over and over, an entire business strategy centered on essentially subsidizing shipper costs to build out a network. But I think there are different ways to think about it. One approach might be to develop a network because you want to leverage purely technology to, what you believe, capture and keep that network. And we've seen that fail a couple of times, because again, it's way more than that. The nuance is way deeper than that. The relationships matter a lot more than that. I said this at a conference recently: one of the reasons I don't see people and brokers getting replaced is because AI bots don't have throats to choke. At the end of the day, transportation managers need a throat to choke. It's not that they have to do it all the time, but they need the ability to do it. And if you don't have a relationship with someone, then you don't have confidence that you can lean on them when you need to get shit done, or hold them accountable when shit isn't getting done.
[32:54] Jesse:
Fully agree. It's interesting, because I've always been quite interested in this idea of how you scale a brokerage to a billion dollars. And it seems like there's a fine line between growing really quickly and then blowing up, and growing really quickly as part of a strategy. In your example, you're making a strategic bet: hey, we're gonna cover this, we're not gonna make much money here, but this is gonna give us the density to then go and win these three other bids and actually make more money. It seems much more nuanced. I'm curious how that plays into the phase of the cycle that you're in, and this mix of contract and spot. As I understand it, in your prior business you were maybe a little bit more contract-heavy than some other large brokers, and I'm curious if that was how you thought about answering the question of what's the optimal split. How do you even make that decision?
[34:12] Andrew:
Yeah, so a couple things. I never really felt like we got to a true maturation point at my last business. What I mean by that is feeling like we really had the dense enough network that I wanted. So there are two ways to think about it. One is, once you're a mature company and you're kinda just riding the market, that's when you're managing the contract-to-spot split much more intensely. If you feel like the market's heading in the down direction, you want to load up on contract and put yourself in a position where maybe you're sixty, even sixty-five percent contract. Whereas on the flip side, as the market's going the other direction and rates are going up, you want a much lower contract exposure. But even within that, it's nuanced to the point of understanding which contract customers you're gonna see benefit from going deep with, where they have special spot business you can get exposed to when the market's really tight. Who are the ones that are really good partners when the market's tight? And I don't mean good partners because they say you can raise your rates by twenty percent across the board. I mean that if things get really ugly and you're managing a book of business that is unsustainable, they wanna partner with you and help you figure out how to manage that in a way that benefits both parties.
[36:06] Andrew:
This is just another example of something I never would do. I wouldn't just call up these customers and say, hey, we're raising your rates by 25% because we're not making money. By the time I was talking to one of these customers about our rates being a problem, they'd already gotten rate increases from every other broker in their network. And our conversation was usually more around, how do we get more business from these other guys that are raising their rates on you? How do we get market-rated business from those guys to offset what we're losing on this stuff we quoted eight months ago, where the rates are simply out of touch with the current market? Those are just different kinds of conversations. But back to your comment around whether we were heavier on contract than other larger brokerages. I don't know specifically, but I know we were pretty heavy on contract, and that was pretty intentional, because we were so heavily focused on network development. To me, the carrier network should never be done being developed. It's just not possible. It's always changing. And my philosophy is, the challenging part of developing a carrier network, and just being a broker in general, is if you want it to work, you have to be willing to trust other people first, and you have to risk getting burned. And it's easy to get burned in this business.
[37:25] Jesse:
What do you mean by that? Say more.
[37:30] Andrew:
I mean, we get a contract from a water company from LA to Phoenix for nine hundred bucks. I'm making up numbers; it's been a while since I've moved a load, so my rates are off. And we get a carrier, it's a down market, and they agree to take it for eight hundred bucks, and they'll be the owned carrier on it. We're giving it to them when we could probably cover it for six fifty on the spot market, but we know that in the peak, it's gonna be twelve hundred. So for three months it's going great. And then they call us one day as the market's getting hot and say, hey, we can't take them anymore. That's gonna happen. And my philosophy is, if you want to build strong relationships with this network in this industry, you have to be willing to trust first, and also be comfortable getting burned from time to time. And when you get burned, you gotta learn from it and move on. There's a way to really go deep with carriers and customers if you're willing to develop trust, but you can't do it if you're not willing to put yourself out there first. And often there's such a negative connotation or feeling around brokers, carriers, shippers even, that no one just leads with trust. It's not instinctive to start with trust and say, yeah, I'm confident you're not gonna steal my loads, I'm confident you'll still be here when the market gets tight. That's not really how this industry is. So you kinda gotta be willing to zig when others zag and develop a business centered on that, while being mindful of the fact that it's not a hundred percent foolproof. You are gonna get burned from time to time.
[39:13] Jesse:
Yeah. I feel like there's a life lesson in that. I've often tried to just start with trust and accept that there are some people in some scenarios that will take advantage of that, and that is just gonna happen. But it doesn't mean it's not the right strategy in general, because you can often just get to better outcomes quickly. In those scenarios, if you get burnt by a carrier, are you working with that carrier again? Or is your stance, hey, I'm gonna trust you, but there are not two chances on this kind of thing, if you violate my trust you're done? How do you think about running that strategy of trust first at its best?
[40:04] Andrew:
Yeah, so I think for one, you need really strong leaders throughout the business, mid-level leaders who can manage this stuff, because they need to be able to have those top-to-top conversations and level set: hey, we made a deal. We all knew when we booked this with you that for the first three months you were getting them at 800 bucks, and we could have covered them for less. We chose not to do that. You have to make the choice now. Despite the fact we had an agreement, you're gonna break that, and you want a thousand or twelve hundred now. Okay, but we won't do another contract with you. That doesn't necessarily mean you have to kick them out of the network. It's very situational, but I certainly wouldn't be putting them on another contract lane where you're paying them over market for a period of time. If someone can still service your freight... there are different types of carriers. There are carriers that you only call at five o'clock out of Chicago, out of certain areas, that you just know aren't even looking to cover their trucks until whoever's on their last loads of the day calls them. And some of them are still really strong carriers. You know they're gonna move the load and get it done. So that's what they are. Keep them in your back pocket for that.
[41:29] Andrew:
I think you asked earlier, and I didn't get to answer, what's changed in the last 10 or 15 years. I think the most important thing that's changed is our ability to meet carriers where they are, and meet shippers where they want to be. There are different ways to move freight, primarily through technology, but even just structurally through technology, if you think about API pricing. There are changes taking place that allow carriers to book loads in ways they couldn't before. I had a lot of owner-operators who were not from the USA, and for some of them English was not their first language. We got by, but their life would have been a lot easier, and they probably could have managed their business better, if they could have just been using the phone and doing everything in Spanish from the onset. We have to be malleable. I've always had this three-pronged approach to customers in brokerage: one prong of our customer base being the carrier, one prong being the shipper, and the last actually being the employee. And you have to be very mindful of how the world changes, even just year over year, in terms of what these people want, what they expect, what they can get on the open market, whether it's a carrier getting a load on the open market, an employee getting a job on the open market, or a shipper picking another broker. You have to keep your ear to the floor and understand what changes you have to make to keep up and continue to be able to service people the way they want to be serviced.
[43:16] Jesse:
Yeah, it's super interesting. Some ideas that I'm thinking about for ourselves, even. Andrew, you're starting to think about your next thing. I think maybe officially your non-compete is close to getting there.
[43:31] Andrew:
We're getting there.
[43:33] Jesse:
Tell me a little bit about how you're thinking about the next thing. It sounds like there's appetite to get back in the game.
[43:45] Andrew:
Yeah, if you want to start simply, I wanna be brokering freight. When will this go out? Any idea?
[43:54] Jesse:
Probably two weeks, three weeks. November.
[43:56] Andrew:
Yeah, I would say by the time this is out, my non-compete's over, which is crazy. Just feeling free, feeling like I can do something. It's a weird feeling knowing that you can't do something you enjoy for a long period of time. But in any case, I do want to get back to brokering freight. I want to be running a freight brokerage. The first question we had to answer is, do you build something from scratch or buy something? And for me, I think in either case you're building. Even if you buy something, I wouldn't buy something because I want to maintain it. My belief, when we started MoLo in 2017, was that I wanted to build a top five broker. Even in selling to ArcBest, the intent was to become a top company in the industry. That hasn't changed, and I actually think I have more confidence in myself and the team I'll build, in our ability to be a top competitor in the space. I'm more confident in that today than ever. And so I don't think building from scratch makes sense, for a couple of reasons.
[45:17] Jesse:
Yeah, I'm curious to understand that a little bit more. Why not?
[45:24] Andrew:
For one, I don't wanna waste two to three years going from zero to two hundred million in top line. That network building piece, it's really hard. It takes a long time. There's no speed running that. You have to do that work. And there are just challenges that you deal with as a new player that I don't feel like we should have to deal with. A simple solution to that is buying an active quality player, and then putting your imprint on it, right? Deploying your principles, learning from what they're already doing, while also adding the flavor of how we already know how to broker freight. Even just thinking about calling a shipper today as a new potential provider and saying, hey, regardless of who you are, who you know, I'm a new broker that's been in business for two weeks, we'd like to haul for you. In a post-Montgomery world, that sounds so unattractive to a shipper, from my perspective. At this point, strong process, compliance, carrier network, these are things that matter if I'm a shipper evaluating providers, and it's just not likely you have strengths in any of that if you're a new company. So for me, I wanna buy something that's already strong in the areas of carrier compliance and carrier development, and just has a foundation. I don't have specific ideas in mind of what that foundation needs to look like. I just wanna buy into something that's good today, whether they're really good at flatbed and specialized, or really good at intermodal, or really good at drayage, or really good at moving water. It doesn't matter to me, because I'm thinking way longer term, way bigger picture. I see the top 100 freight broker list, and whatever company I'm part of, we gotta be a top five company there. And if we start with drayage, if we start with intermodal, if we start with whatever, that doesn't matter. That works, because we can build on top of it. Executing for a customer at the highest level, that sells whether you're moving on trains, planes, or automobiles. So that's kind of how I'm thinking about it. And until the non-compete ends, I can't really go deep to make a deal happen. So unfortunately I don't think I'll be moving loads the first day my non-compete ends, but I'm hopeful that within probably one to two months of my non-compete ending, we'll have a company signed, sealed, delivered, and be back in business and moving freight.
[48:32] Jesse:
Does it feel like folks are gonna be transacting? Does it seem like a good time to be able to enter?
[48:43] Andrew:
Yeah, I don't know that most freight brokerage owners will admit this, but they should be pretty scared.
[48:57] Jesse:
Say more. I'm curious.
[48:59] Andrew:
When we owned MoLo, we were constantly afraid, and that was before Montgomery. You naturally are afraid that all the time, energy, and effort that you and your team have put into building something... I was always afraid it was gonna go away for anything. Just that someone was gonna trip in the street walking out of the building, and boom, the business is gone because they sue us. You live in this state of fear as a business owner. It's just how it is. Some days we'd walk in and be like, this is the best business ever, we're doing so great, I love everything we're doing. The next day you walk in and it's like, the sky is falling, I don't know how we're gonna make it through the month. So now you add in this Montgomery stuff, where not even future accidents but past accidents are on the table, and you get a lawsuit, and it just could be over quickly. And the lack of clarity, the general ambiguity around what is negligence, what is safe, what is vetting... no one's defining it for you. It's not gonna be defined until you're sitting in a courtroom and a jury defines it for you. And what is the likelihood that they're gonna be favorable to the freight broker versus the very tragic, grieving family? There's a lot of messiness to that whole thing, and we don't have to go into all of it, but my point is just that I do think a lot of deals are gonna happen in the next year. I think a lot of them are gonna be people who've been in this business for ten to thirty years and have put their blood, sweat, and tears and everything they have into this, and they've probably built a good business, whether it's worth ten million or fifty million or two hundred. Everyone's different, but it's worth a lot more than if they get some bad accident that craters them.
[51:10] Andrew:
And so I think naturally that will lead people to think... and then the other side of this is, forget the Montgomery stuff for a minute. Just think about AI. You can't scroll through five minutes of Twitter without seeing a tweet talking about how there won't be jobs in five years and we'll all be getting a stipend from OpenAI, whatever. And it's not enough to think, I need to run now and quit my job or sell my company, but it's just enough that if you weren't some savvy tech founder or CEO and you didn't really know how to deploy this stuff, you might be like, maybe it's time to cash my chips. Because who knows. The generation that runs businesses today is very different than the generation, like yourself, who are going to weaponize, in the best ways and maybe unfortunately the worst ways, this new technology that is developing rapidly before us.
[52:25] Jesse:
So for you, is your bet on entering... do you have a point of view that, hey, given these risks, here's how I'm gonna approach it? Or is it more of a bet on yourself, which is, you're an entrepreneur, you're gonna be able to navigate this stuff, freight is gonna need to get moved, and you're just underwriting your ability to navigate it? Some things have changed. Montgomery is certainly a very real and potentially very large thing. AI could just be a continuation of what it means to become more efficient, or maybe there is some discontinuity; I'm not sure anyone fully knows. I'm curious your take on how you're gonna navigate those things, and this decision that, look, I'm getting back in the game regardless.
[53:26] Andrew:
Yeah, it's a good question, and a couple of thoughts. For one, I was thinking it before you even said it, and you kind of said it differently: someone's gotta move the freight. At the end of the day, someone's gotta move the freight, why not me? Right? And to me that's just the competitive mindset I have. I'll find a group of people like myself who think they can beat anyone. If you put us in the same game as everyone else, we think we can win. That's the team we want to build. At the end of the day, someone's got to move the freight. And so there are a lot of questions. But when there's a lack of clarity, there's usually an opportunity to make money. I'm not saying I'm some savant at that at all, not even remotely. But what I do believe is that eventually there will be clarity in what safe looks like. Until that point, I think there are things you can do in practice to go over the top and really invest heavily in protecting yourself. My perspective is, over-invest in the protection until the clarity exists. You kind of want to manage the storm and let the people who get too scared get weeded out. Maybe you scoop some of them, or scoop some of their business along the way. That's kind of my philosophy on the Montgomery stuff. Aaron Graf said this when I interviewed him: the economy just doesn't work if these nuclear verdicts become more pertinent. The world stops functioning at some point when every truck accident is a nine-figure deal. It can't. I understand the complexity, sadness, and challenge of putting a value on a human life, but it is something that at some point someone has to do, in a way that allows accountability to be had but also the world to operate. And there will always be a need for people to move stuff. So that's my perspective on the Montgomery thing.
[55:38] Andrew:
On the AI thing, it's similar. I don't think anyone today in the brokerage world is an expert yet. It's too early for anyone to be an expert, in my opinion. So I'm not really worried about being too far behind. I think we can be at parity with the top players. I could see a path where in five or ten years there actually is real consolidation in the brokerage space. I didn't believe that historically. I can see it now. And I think with the right team, in time, I can get to the point where we're at the top with the four to five others that survived this. And I think if you put our principles against the public, short-sighted mindset of the other top players that would still exist, I think we win. I just wanna be in the game when all that's left are the big bad ones. Not bad in a negative way, but just the big ones.
[56:42] Jesse:
I know what you mean. Yeah.
[56:47] Andrew:
And maybe this is all made up in my head. I don't know. Whatever gets me to want to show up fired up to work and compete, I'll live in that fairy tale. Because we don't have to know what the future looks like. We just gotta show up and do the work, if we're willing to bet on ourselves and bet on our team, right? So yeah, I don't know.
[57:05] Jesse:
Yeah. One of the things I'm constantly impressed with is, you just see people in freight that execute really, really well, and they build businesses that grow. And they seem to do that throughout the market cycle, because service quality is a lot about whether you can execute really, really well at scale, and a lot of that is grit and hustle and perseverance. So I think you're gonna do it. Super cool. Andrew, I've really enjoyed this conversation. We're coming up on time. I'm curious, fast forward twelve months from now, what would this conversation look and feel like? You can take that in a few ways. What do you hope for yourself? What do you think the problems are that you're gonna be tackling? What do you think the state of the industry is? How could the world be different? What might be more clear, less clear?
[58:21] Andrew:
That's a hard question. Here's what I'll say. Twelve months from now, so we're October, November of 2027. What will I be doing? I don't know. I just wanna be happily running a brokerage at that point, a real brokerage. It's crazy for me to think about. It's been three and a half years.
[59:00] Andrew:
A year from now, I better be on a flight to go see a new potential customer that we've been hauling for for three months, who just found out about us because we've done so much freight for them out of nowhere. My favorite part of brokerage is that first part of a new relationship, where you really show up and they kind of look at you like, how did you get this much business so quickly? That happened to me with Rich Products when I was maybe 22 at Coyote. It was one of my first real customers, and we only got loads because it was the middle of summer and no one wanted to go to Florida anymore because it was August. I sent an email to the head guy saying that we could give him trucks from Murfreesboro, Tennessee, their plant there, going to Florida, and he must have been so busy that he just forwarded it to their managed transportation team. They called me asking if I could take a load to Louisiana from Tennessee. And I was like, I'll take whatever load you got. And I took 120 loads in the next month. And then the guy emailed me and said, I need you to come to Buffalo, New York, because I don't really know who the hell you guys are and how you got this many loads. And it's like, well, we showed up and we just wanted to grow, and your team asked us if we could cover them, and we covered them. That to me is the most fun part of this business: there's so much opportunity out there. If you just do the work, the sky is the limit. And it's never going anywhere. I keep meeting people who run these super niche businesses, moving things I didn't even know existed, and the companies they're moving for don't have TMSs. They're still faxing stuff. The industry's just so big. I just wanna be busy as hell moving loads a year from now. I'm sorry, that's not some super philosophical answer.
[1:00:56] Jesse:
Doesn't need to be. It's not supposed to be. This is the thing I love about operating companies: you just show up every day and you're solving the next problem, and you're building, and you kinda blink and look back and you're like, wow. It felt like you were just solving problems, and then you stacked so many of those and you look back and it was super rewarding. And then you get right back in: all right, where are we going next, what's the next problem to solve? I'm gonna be curious to hear from you in twelve months. Prior to starting this company, I worked with private equity funds, and we would buy, grow, scale, and exit other businesses. People say starting a company is super hard, and it's certainly challenging, but for me, emotionally, when you start something from the ground up, you're pushing the water uphill, and then you get some people on board and it starts to compound, and you are the business. You've been there from the beginning, you know the whole story, you have all this credibility. When I took over other people's businesses, I was twenty-eight years old. I had a couple of years of professional experience. I was buying companies from forty-five-year-old guys who'd run massive companies and then started their own, and they were selling to me, who'd never done anything. You're gonna be in a very different position. You're still young in your career, but you've done stuff, you've started companies.
[1:03:00] Andrew:
I don't know about that. But go ahead. I do know what you're saying.
[1:03:02] Jesse:
So your status will obviously be very different. I had people literally saying, I don't know, man, I don't know if we trust him, he hasn't really been around very long. But you're also inheriting a lot of culture that you want to evolve to be something that feels like your own. And to your point about how culture is so important, it's also very effing hard to change it. I found that emotionally the most difficult part is: you inherit a thing, what do you honor? What do you change? Who do you keep? Who do you not? Sometimes it's a little bit of brute force, whereas it's a little bit easier when it's your baby and you started it from the beginning. You're just super clear on what is me and my business and what's not, so we're gonna cut that. I'm gonna be curious to see what your experience is like in that, because I felt like it's quite different.
[1:04:05] Andrew:
Yeah, so I'll add something then to my answer, thinking in the context of buying a business. The funny thing here is how open-minded I am to the type of business that we would buy. And I'll be clear, it wouldn't be my money. I'd be partnering with private equity to buy something. This could be something that's forty people, it could be something that's a hundred people, it could be something that's thirteen hundred people. I'm pretty open-minded to what it could be, and the opportunity is there. So it's hard, because one day I'll sit and think, okay, if we were to go after this company, this is what it looks like. You spend a lot of time in your head thinking about how you'd come into that place and what challenges you'd run into with personalities, because there is this existing foundation, but you also are gonna have to bring in a lot of people to get it to where you want it to go.
[1:05:31] Andrew:
What I was thinking about is, twelve months from now, if I've done this right, if we go this path and buy a company, whether it's fifty people or thirteen hundred, and I can say confidently I don't think it would be bigger than something like that, but within that range anything could happen, fifty versus twelve hundred is so different... my point would just be that twelve months from now, wherever I am, I want it to feel like home, in terms of what I want the business to look and feel like, but also for all the people who work there to feel the same way. Which just means that a year in, we're all aligned. We're all rowing in the right direction. We all believe in the same thing. I don't think that I have all the answers. I'm actually pretty confident I don't have most of them. But I have a few that I'm pretty confident in, with respect to principles for how to run a brokerage, that are pretty inarguable. You'd have a hard time arguing with me that treating carriers with respect is a bad move. So I don't think it's hard to get people bought into the things that I believe in, because they're not unique to me, and there's a lot of truth, and the proof is in the pudding in terms of what they look like in operation. So I'm eager to just go learn from and be part of a team again. Part of three and a half years without a job is there's a desperation to be part of a team. It's not a big team running a podcast. It's not a big team on the golf course. My pickleball team is usually just my wife, or a couple of guys I play with, but it's one other person on the team. So yeah, I miss that, and I'm really looking forward to being back as part of that.
[1:07:19] Jesse:
Amazing. Well, I'm excited to see what you do, and we'll be cheering you on. Thanks so much for the conversation.
[1:07:25] Andrew:
Thanks.